4.15.2009

Collegiate NBA Squads

For no real reason whatsoever, I found myself wondering as I fell asleep last night which NCAA program could put together the best starting 5 of current NBA players. Without a doubt, Wake Forest has the best top players, boasting a Big Three of Tim Duncan, Chris Paul, and Josh Howard, but there's only one other Demon Deacon in the whole league (Darius Songaila), so they're eliminated from the tourney.
Since it's my Spring Break, and since I'm at my sister's (who has a working computer), and since I don't have a car to take me anywhere, and since it's raining outside, and since I'm a dork, I spent the past few hours researching and putting together starting 5s. The fruits of my labor:

UConn Huskies
PG Ben Gordon
SG Ray Allen
SF Caron Butler
PF Rudy Gay
C Emeka Okafor
Bench: Rip Hamilton, Charlie Villanueva
A top contender for sure, but not very well-balanced and without a real point guard. This team could shoot jumpers all day, with Okafor just sitting down low to grab their misses and kick 'em back out, but I don't see them being able to stop anybody from scoring either.

Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets
PG Stephon Marbury
SG Jarrett Jack
SF Thaddeus Young
PF Matt Harpring
C Chris Bosh
Bench: Will Bynum
Not really that high on talent level, but I included them just because I was surprised they could field a squad at all. Also it's notable that everyone here is essentially at their natural position.

Kansas Jayhawks
PG Mario Chalmers
SG Kirk Hinrich
SF Paul Pierce
PF Drew Gooden
C Darrell Arthur
Bench: Brandon Rush
Pretty lame big men, but the Truth gives them enough legitimacy to be in the conversation.

North Carolina Tarheels
PG Raymond Felton
SG Vince Carter
SF Marvin Williams
PF Antawn Jamison
C Rasheed Wallace
Bench: Brendan Haywood, Jerry Stackhouse
I wasn't really sure if Stack was still alive or not, but if he is and he can still play basketball I'd probably plug him in at 2, move Carter to 3, and bump Marvin Williams. Kind of shocking, though, that UNC hasn't produced anybody to supplant Stack-Sheed/Carter-Jamison in the past 10-12 years. I don't really see Psycho T doing that NBA-wise, either.

Duke Blue Devils
PG Chris Duhon
SG Luol Deng
SF Corey Maggette
PF Carlos Boozer
C Elton Brand
Bench: Grant Hill, Shane Battier, Mike Dunleavy, JJ Redick
Undoubtedly the deepest bench, which is not surprising considering that Duke has been producing NBA bench players for 25 years now. This is a good, deep group, but they would have looked a lot better a year ago, before Brand and Boozer had serious injuries, and when Maggette was still looking solid in LA.

Florida Gators
PG Corey Brewer
SG Mike Miller
SF Udonis Haslem
PF David Lee
C Al Horford
Bench: Matt Bonner, Joakim Noah
Probably the best defensive squad here, especially with Haslem, Lee and Horford hitting the boards. Still, not a lot of star power or firepower other than Miller and Bonner bombing from outside.

Arizona Wildcats
PG Gilbert Arenas
SG Jason Terry
SF Richard Jefferson
PF Andre Iguodala
C Channing Frye
Bench: Mike Bibby, Luke Walton
Along with UConn, probably the most talented group, but with the same sort of positional problems and absolutely no legit big men. Everybody (well, everybody but Channing Frye) is gonna want to have the ball in their hands and put it through the hoop. And Arenas/Terry/Jefferson all essentially have the same game. Still, they'd score at will.

Texas Longhorns
PG TJ Ford
SG Boobie Gibson
SF Kevin Durant
PF LaMarcus Aldridge
C Chris Mihm
Bench: DJ Augustin
This actually turned out to be my favorite squad, and I think they'd have a chance to win. Everyone is at their natural position. You've got one of the top 10 players in the league (Durant), a legit big man (Aldridge), outside shooting (Gibson) and a solid ball-handler (TJ Ford). But then there's Chris Mihm. If I was the coach of this team, I'd probably play as much small-ball as I could get away with, plugging Augustin in at the point and playing with three guards, Durant and Aldridge.

UCLA Bruins
PG Baron Davis
SG Jason Kapono
SF Trevor Ariza
PF Matt Barnes
C Kevin Love
Bench: Russell Westbrook, Jordan Farmar
A team of role players with Diddy as the focal point? It could work: Diddy drives, draws defenders, kicks out to Kapono for the three. Diddy drives, draws defenders, lays off to Ariza for the jam. Diddy drives, throws up a wildly ambitious layup that clanks off the rim, Barnes and Love grab the board. Yes, this is probably the least-talented group here, but you have to think of the team dynamic.

OK those were the best nine teams I came up with. Who do you guys think takes it? Is there another school out there that could compete that I'm forgetting? Are there other players from these schools that I've overlooked?

5 comments:

  1. So, there is definitely a lack of quality big men (that aren't very young). I'm guessing this is because until recently, most awesome big men jumped straight from high school. Anyway, I think Wake Forest can field a team. Chris Paul at PG, Josh Howard at SF, Darius Songaila at PF, and Tim Duncan at C. Now currently, those are the only wake players in the NBA. But 3 of them are awesome. So for SG, I'm choosing Rusty Larue. He played with the Bulls in 1998, The Jazz in 2001-2002, and the Celtics and Warriors in 2003. He's played in Europe in as well. Plug him into a guard spot to fill space (much like Songaila at PF), and let Paul, Howard, and Duncan carry the team. I think they could. Technically, to qualify for Sovic's parameters, Rusty Larue would have to be resigned by an nba team. But I'm sure the Clips or Kings would give him another shot. They suck.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i'm very disappointed that uva didn't make the list. love the post, though. was well worth the long wait (ok maybe not but it's certainly appreciated).

    i'm going with unc to take the crown. they can't play any D but they'll score on anybody and felton is a much better pg than anyone on uconn. couple years down the road, and find any other warm body at C, and i could see texas winning it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. However, if I had to choose from these teams above, I would probably choose UNC (even though I hate to agree with BArdey). If Zona had a moderate big man, I could see choosing them. The texas lineup isn't bad either. Let Durant carry them. But I think I'll wait until June, when Wake has more players in the nba. As Bardey pointed out, James Johnson and Jeff Teague will be in the nba. Then I'll plug a random in and let Duncan, Howard, and Paul dominate.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wake can be reinstated if you count Loren Woods. I know he transferred to Zona but he was once a Deacon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. LSU wouldn't be the best one but they have some big, interesting characters:
    Shaquille O'Neal
    Tyrus Thomas
    Brandon Bass
    Stromile Swift
    Glen Davis

    ReplyDelete